Black Longwear Waterproof Crème Color

Literally garbage. It smears and smudges and transfers. Not worth the test—try a different brand.

I wanted to love this. It glides on easily making winged liner quick and sharp. But it smears. Everywhere. I have tried eyeshadow primers, powders, setting it with eyeshadow, setting sprays. Nothing can combat this smudges.

Love it. I paid my own money to get this and even i tried on my hand and wash my hand twice but it didnt came off. Its a genuine review and i like it

This is the worst eyeliner I’ve ever used. I’m a Bridal Makeup Artist for over 20 years now and I’ve never been more embarrassed every time I use this product. Every single person came back to me needing a touch up with their eyes, completely smeared and raccooned the crazy part is I knew this eyeliner was giving me trouble so I only put it on the top part of lid , i did not put it on the bottom or in the waterline and they still had raccoon eyes. What an embarrassment then I tried setting it with some powder and still later they had raccoon eyes makes me look like a terrible artist.

Worst gel liner i’ve used. Smudges and runs like crazy. I have tried using with setting powder and spray in the hopes it would work, complete waste of money. Do not buy, j

It has potential but does not stay for long, I like waterproof or long-lasting but it came off after 2 hours

The pigment is great, which is why I gave it to stars but it transfers and smudge is like crazy unfortunately

This, along with the liner brush makes it easier for me to apply eyeliner, since I'm still a beginner and don't have completely steady hands. Also I was heavily rained on and got splashed by a car, and the eyeliner still stayed put. Although it DID dry out, so I just mixed a drop of baby oil, and it actually made it even better.

I love make up but this eyeliner isn’t water proof and it smudges so bad. Wet and wild is way better then this

This is a lovely, inky eyeliner, but it burned my eyes so badly. I've never reacted to eyeliner before, but this one is so harsh on the skin