Sam Edelman Women's Sylvia Wide-Calf Dress Boots

Very comfortable boots, don’t feel like wearing heals at all

The boots fit really well and are immediately comfortable. I was worried the wide calf option would look too wide, but they don’t. They look great and fit great.

I am absolutely in love with these boots and was so upset that they didn’t fit. After measuring calf, the wide Boot should have been enough but it was sooooo tight. Definitely get an extra wide if you normally wear wide calf boots.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Great quality and fit classic brown suede boot

These boots are absolutely gorgeous. The leather is so soft. They were a Christmas gift for my daughter. I originally bought the standard calf but she felt they were a little too snug. So we tried the wide calf and they were way too big so we ended up returning both pair. We then went in store to Macys to try other boots and there were none left in her size. We were kind of rudely told that boot season was over. It's the first week of January and boot season is over?? I don't understand stores.

Beautiful boots, soft leather, good hill height and very comfortable

This is a nice boot. The regular calf would have been too tight. My only issue is that the zipper sticks out from the boot which I don’t like. The other thing that drove me nuts is the neon green stickers on the soles of the boot announcing “Wide Calf” it’s so hard to remove and I scraped up the soles trying to remove. Please stop doing this.

Boots seem comfortable on initial try on, but they are not designed for shorter gals. They seem better suited for ladies 5’ 6” and taller. The material is fine.

Let me de-influence you from buying these. If you want to wear them occasionally, sure. But these are not everyday boots. Ive had them a month and they scratch incredibly easily and the leather at the toes have worn down A LOT considering i’ve only worn them a handful of times. Granted, I live in NYC and i’ve worn them around on the streets but i have must less expensive shoes that have held up a lot better. They also aren’t the most comfortable.

I originally order the 8.5 wide calf. The boot fit, but the calf was tight. I returned them and ordered an 8W, extra wide calf. The calf is perfect, but the boot fits a little snug in the ankle area. Hopefully they will stretch a little after wear. I think the 8.5 wide will be too big.