Johnston & Murphy Men's Melton Cap Toe Oxford

My mother-in-law asked me, "Who shined your shoes, the Marines?"

A rare fine all leather shoe. Is comfortable and fashionable.

Best made shoe quality, hands down. Old school craftsmanship with leather soles. Perfect fit and also being comfortable. Shoes of this caliber are hard to find. Own 3 different color Melons with this tan pair completing my wardrobe.

6th pair and still the best shoe investment I have ever made. Looks amazing, comfortable, durable. Need I say more? You get what you pay for.

Great looking dress shoe. The cslf skin leather is soft and flexible. Shines great. Comfortable right out of the box.

Looking for this shoe in burgundy. You once sold it in burgundy. I desire to buy.

Runs true to size for dress shoes. I have wide feet, these are great. Very comfortable. Look great with a suit, appreciate a leather sole.

Exceptionally well made. My last pair went more than 15 years (new soles and heels). This will likely take me through retirement.

Nice leather, stylish lines complete designer look

These are clearly high-quality dress shoes with excellent materials and craftsmanship. The leather looks great and feels durable, and the overall construction is solid. That said, they are noticeably stiff out of the box and require a longer break-in period than expected. They also run wide, so if you have narrow feet, the fit may be an issue even with proper sizing. One downside is the two-piece insole, which started to peel up fairly easily and feels like a weak point compared to the rest of the shoe. Overall, a well-made shoe with premium looks, but comfort and fit may not work for everyone.