Randolph Bit

The shoes are true to size.

I have 13 pairs of AE shoes that I actively wear (and many more that are retired) including 4 other pairs of Randolph loafers all in the same size. My initial impression was they were a little tight, but would loosen up over time and it was the same shoe that I purchased many times before. These shoes are so tight I cannot wear them more than a few hours at a time and have quit wearing them altogether. Very disappointed.

Wore these for my wedding and received compliments. A little uncomfortable at first but needed to be broken in and molded to my foot. I love Allen Edmonds.

I love the shoe and have been wearing it now for 2 months, but it's still a bit tight. Been trying to stretch it out to find that "worn-in" comfort, but my usual D width seems to have been too narrow. And I don't recall a larger width being available for this shoe when I purchased it online.

i want a second pair in different color. very beautiful shoes.

Exceptional quality, comfortable and look spectacular. I'm very happy with this purchase.

I don't believe the quality of the leather is the same as my older AE shoes.

I am very happy with my purchase of the Allen Edmund's Randolph bit loafer.

Very elegant loafer, comfortable but requires breaking in. You should half size up.

Long time customer of AE but extremely disappointed on these bit loafers navy. I've kept with AE cedar shoe trees and have work once. After the day was done I looked down and they had so many deep creases in the toe box. Shoes appears like they had years of wear on them from someone that doesn't take care of their shoes. Extremely disappointed on these. Less then 70 days of ownership and one full day of wear.