BADgal BANG! Volumizing Waterproof Mascara

I originally tried the regular version because of recommendations. I loved the lengthening effect but it was very smudgy. So I tried the waterproof with high hopes but it was just as smudgy if not worse. Very disappointed

I've been using this for one week. I didn't initially have any irritation but I noticed it was REALLY, REALLY hard to get off, even for waterproof mascara. It also hurt to get off of my eyelashes because it basically glues them in place and I had to be super gentle when removing. I thought I could live with it being difficult to get off because it kept my stick-straight lashes curled all day and didn't transfer - a first to do both. And then I woke up this morning thinking I had pink eye - nope, contact dermatitis. It's Sunday, I haven't worn it since Friday but even after roughly 5-6 face washes including the initial waterproof makeup removing cleansing oil I used Friday night, I am still seeing black specks that won't come off and after inspecting my irritated eye, I noticed 3 significant bald spots in my lash line between both eyes. I'm really upset about both the level of irritation and the eyelash loss I'm experiencing, I don't know what's in this but geezus someone needs to change the formula this is crazy

this is lowkey the best mascara ive ever used. the application was a bit intimidating at first because the formula is so thick but eventually i got the hang of it!! it makes my lashes look absolutely unreal, i constantly get asked if theyre fake. my lashes are a bit on the longer side, but theyre super straight. ill curl them once before applying this mascara and the curl will stay all day. i was worried about the removal process but it honestly isnt too bad.

Applies great, looks fine at first but the smudging underneath the eyes after an hour or so is insane. I went to work the other day trying this for the first time. Didn't think anything of it and honestly forgot I used a new product. Only worked a few hours this day & I got home, I went to go wash my face like I normally would & for the first time saw myself in the mirror and I looked like a raccoon. Like, worst smudging I have ever gotten from a mascara or any product. It was astonishing how much black I had under my eyes.

I have naturally long and curled eyelashes and this mascara basically just made my eyelashes darker. I did not notice any lengthening or added volume. However I am very particular about my mascara so I might just be judging it too hard, but the drugstore mascara I use is so much better in my opinion.

I go back to this mascara time and time again. It doesn’t smudge and the black pigment is perfect. It also does not irritate my eyes despite wearing contact lenses.

Not waterproof. This mascara smudged on me multiple times when wearing all day for work. Didn’t test through exercises or any type of sweat but would bet that it holds up even worse.

Im not happy with this item cause it does smudge. Even though it claims to be waterproof and 36 hour lasting. Not even one hour and I have mascara on my lower eye lids

I’ve used quite a bit of different mascaras and eye brow pencils. Benefit Cosmetics is my go to for ALL eye liners, mascara, eyebrow pencils, and eyebrow gel. I have sensitive eyes and their products are the absolute best in my opinion. They check all the boxes! This specific mascara is my favorite. I typically use a tubing mascara first, then use this over top for lengthening. I can work a 12 hours shift at the restaurant serving and have no issues with smudging or flaking. I love this brand.

So good! It is very hard to get off but that is what I want from a waterproof mascara! I took a shower and my lashes are still perfect - I know ai shouldn’t but when I put it on I keep it for 2 days and it is perfect!