12HR Colorful Waterproof Retractable Eyeliner

It performed as expected. It did wipe off kind of easily

Very disappointed with this Sephora-brand retractable eyeliner. After only two weeks of use, the entire eyeliner tip/product fell out of the tube and this happened twice. The quality is clearly not what I expected, and unfortunately, Sephora’s customer service was just as disappointing. They refused to replace the product despite the issue happening more than once. I won’t be purchasing this eyeliner again. Next time, I’ll choose a different brand and purchase directly from the company.

The pigment is not as strong as I was hoping for - returned! Good price though -

I have been using this almost daily for about two weeks now. it definitely isn’t 12 hr. it glides on so nicely though and i have been picking this one the most to wear. I’m still on the hunt for a true long lasting pencil eyeliner, but this will do for now.

Pencil is a bit soft and hard to control. Stays on all day. It’s an ok product but will not buy again.

threw up at a party and went to sleep right after. was still on my eyes when i woke up. cute colour too, looks great on brown eyes

Tried this on a whim as I use all types of eyeliners from urban decay, makeup by Mario , wonderskin , Clinique but this one wow works and stays put even on my waterline. Just purchased 5 more colors.

I really wanted to love this… but it didn’t happen I was very disappointed in it. It disappeared within a couple of hours and I looked awful.. came right off my waterline. Will not buy again only used a few times definitely not worth the money

I bought this eyeliner hoping it wouldn’t smudge throughout the day. It’s incredibly affordable compared to other eyeliners I’ve tried that have smudged. In short, I use it to slightly open my eyes, even when I’m going makeup-free with just mascara and eyeliner. I went swimming and hiking with it on, and it held up pretty well. I noticed a bit of smudging when I was getting ready to leave, but it was perfectly fine while I was out and about.

Received it as a part of an educational promotion.I’ve been using the Sephora Retractable Eyeliner in the shade Chocolate Matte Brown, and I really like how smoothly it glides on. The texture is creamy, so it’s easy to apply without tugging at the skin. The shade isn’t a very deep brown, so on my brown skin it gives a soft, subtle brown tint on both my eyelids and waterline rather than a bold look. I think it would show up a bit brighter on lighter skin tones. It’s a great choice for an everyday, natural makeup look. My favorite feature is the built-in smudger—it blends the liner really well and makes it easy to create a soft, smoky effect in just a few seconds.