MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Resist Color Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 0.04 oz.

Horrible update! I still have the previous version of this eyeliner and it was so much better. The new one is shorter (less product), does not twist up (impossible to use), and the packaging feels hollow (cheap). I went to the store today because I wanted one that works and was informed I would have to sharpen it on my own and I would have to purchase a separate sharpener. Why does the end of the pencil twist if it is not going to lengthen and sharpen the product? No one wants anything this difficult to use. I am rushing to get ready in the mornings or touch up later in the day and every second counts. I do not have time for this and will not buy again.

The color is spectacular; it holds up well when I use it on the eyelid, but it doesn't last long when I use it under the eye.

Great color bronze eye pencil a d great performance!

It makes it through my work day, eye drops and all.

This pencil is terrible now that you've removed the sharpener.

Used to be my ride or die eye line. But something has change. Loved their old applicator (no sharpener required) and formula. This new version isnt quite cuttintg it :(

The “twister” on the bottom of the pencil was broken and would not raise the rest of the liner higher, so after I used the initial tip of the liner, I was not able to access the rest. I used the previous aqua resist model in the past and never had this problem.

Been using MUFE aqua resist color pencil #2 Ebony for years. The mechanic twisting packaging was so convenient. I’ve poked my eyes with the new pencil several times and causes me not to have a smooth application. Wish I can have the old packaging back.

Easy glide on formula, rich color, fantastic staying power. I will buy this again and again.

Only eye pencil I have found that does not give me raccoon eyes by the end of my day