Feline Flick Volume 2 Liquid Eyeliner

Beautiful glide and color but dries out extremely fast. Super bummed about this because I hide high hopes

Love the light brown shade BUT a few issues 1. Was NOT tug free making the liner a bit jagedy (not smooth) 2. The dispersal of the product is very uneven and not consistent

**Pic 1: week 2 & Pic 2: month 2 of use** I used KVD’s Tattoo Liner for almost a decade, so switching was something I definitely did not want to do. After the last KVD batch was reformulated and then went out of stock, I had no choice but to look for alternatives. Over the years I had already tried several others, including Stila, One/Size, and Makeup by Mario, but none gave me the same intensity, longevity, or precision, especially with heavy eyeshadow looks and daily wear. While on vacation, a Sephora associate recommended the Charlotte Tilbury Feline Flick liner, and I decided to try it. Even though I was more accustomed to KVD’s tip, I was immediately impressed by how intensely black the pigment was and how precise the lines looked. It worked beautifully for sharp wings and evening makeup, including formal events, and once applied it truly did not budge. I was very happy with the liner during the first two weeks of daily use. After that point, I noticed the flow became slightly harder to control. The liner did not completely dry out, but the consistency required going over the line more than before, which made application take longer and sometimes reduced precision. I often apply liner over eyeshadow, which may also affect how the product performs over time. Given the price point, I do wish the smooth flow lasted longer, but in terms of pigment, definition, and staying power, very few liners compare. If you want a liner that is intensely black, long-wearing, and ideal for defined winged looks or special events, this is still one I would recommend.

Longevity on eye and black color is awesome. However the liner dries out very easily and does not last long, two months. For the price, it’s not worth it if it can’t last longer. Other competitor pens last almost 6 months with daily use.

Not sure why the bad reviews. This eyeliner is definitely on the better side for most liners. Seems to last all day for me.

The color is beautiful. The liner goes on smoothly. It is not too easy to get off with just a cleansing wipe. I also have the black liner but this super brown is a perfect color

It has amazing pigment but transfers so looks like I’m a raccoon after a couple hours so I hope I have time to return this within the 30 day window! Other brands don’t transfer from upper eyelid to lower eyelid. The brush is very soft but I would not purchase again.

I dont know why this product has any negative reviews. its the easiest applicator and if you are looking for BLACK, this is it! I love it.

The brown one leans very reddish brown and if i don’t shake it before using it, then it actually dried red on my lids! Very odd and I’ve used this eyeliner before, the shade definitely looked different than what I remembered

I have loved everything from Charlotte Tilbury (mascara, foundation, eyeshadows), so I was disappointed this eyeliner is a complete flop. The application tip is nice for control, but it doesn't last more than a half day without drying out and crumbling or smudging off. The photos I've shared are after maybe 2 hours of wear. I have tried it with a handful of primers, setters, creme and powder eyeshadows and it doesn't seem to make a difference around the lack of longevity.