Johnston & Murphy Men's Collier Penny Loafers

Silly me, thinking a company like Johnston & Murphy would have consistent sizing across their products. I've worn a men's regular width, size 12 shoe from J&M for years and have not had an issue with consistency. The sizing of this shoe is completely off. Unless you normally wear a narrow width shoe, you'll have issues with these. Sadly, I have to return these since they are unwearable.

I have lots of J&M shoes, and they never disappoint. These loafers are just what I needed for a casual shoe with jeans or shorts. They can be dressed up with some khakis for a dinner, or out by the pool on a lazy afternoon.

Just bought 3 more pairs, different colors. Great look, super comfortable....they need to make black ones.

These loafers are great looking and very comfortable. Purchased my usual size and fit well without much breaking in.

This shoe is very comfortable and well cushioned for extended walking. It looks dressy enough to wear with slacks but is equally casual to be worn with shorts.

These penny loafers are exactly what I wanted. Perfect fit, quality is exceptional (as always), comfortable right out of the box. The leather is soft and has a nice look. Highly recommend if you want a classic look.

Quality, fit and style at a reasonable price, you can’t beat that !

The shoes fit perfect, very comfortable and I love them

I bought three of these shoes in different colors and I like these better than the Peter Millar shoes that were similar, and the Peter Millar's cost twice what the Johnston Murphy shoes cost. These don't wrinkle on the top and the extra sole on the bottom makes them super comfortable. Great shoe!

A perfect company, top quality, great style and color, a GREAT PURCHASE !