Johnston & Murphy Men's Calder Plain Round Toe Shoes

Comfort is good

Good looking shoe that is versatile to wear with casual and dress apparel. Easy for shoe shine.

I bought these on a whim from the store. I like the style and colors, basically perfect for my normal work attire. I am a half size and have never had shoes fit my feet better. It finally feels if they are made for my foot. Usually there's extra room somewhere or slide around a bit. That being said, the topline wants to dig into my achilles area. I've been trying to stretch out that area but I haven't attempted this much, other than just before wearing them. Wore them a few times already. There does appear to be some wear on the sole, so longevity is unknown. 5 stars for fit/comfort at the foot. 2-3 for comfort at the heel. 5 for style. 4 overall and hopeful they brake in at the heel.

After less than 10 wears, the soles are fraying at heels and toes. The shoes are much heavier than I expected. Would not buy them again and I would like to return this pair of shoes.

Shoes were nice but sizing is so off. My husband tried 3 different sizes. There was so much room in the front but they were terribly tight over his mid foot. Had to return.

Very comfortable and beautiful shoe. 4 stars because it’s much darker and more red than shown in the picture

It is a fine shoe. The angle/geometry of the heel upper does not fit my heel well. It has caused a painful rub but only on the left foot. I’m not saying this would be the same experience for anyone else but it is for me. The soles of the shoe may not last particularly well long term. They have seemed to wear fairly quickly. I’ve only worn these shoes about 10 times in the last 30 days. I assumed they would be the same quality as the two other pairs of J&M does that I have, but I’m not so sure. Time will tell. Probably would not recommend to any of my friends but I love my other J&Ms.

Beautiful shoe. Way too skinny compared to their other shoes in my size. If they're going to make them so skinny they should also add a wide version.

These shoes were expensive but totally worth the cost. From the first wear, they were comfortable and they look professional. My hasband thanks me for ordering them every time he wears them!