Clean Volume - Volumizing Tubing Mascara

Returned this product. Very little volume, hard to see I was even wearing mascara. And the removal process was not as easy as Thrive.

For reference, I only use tubing mascaras with brushes that emphasize separation of the lashes. I have naturally quite long but thin lashes. I liked how this applied, though it does look more obviously like mascara (a little clumpier) than the Glossier one. It also flakes slightly, even with only one light coat applied, which is not something I've experienced with other tubing mascaras. I think different tubing mascaras work for different lash types, so it's still worth giving it a try.

I might have gotten a bad batch because yikes. My lashes instantly drop and that’s after curling my lashes which should help but no. The flaking is insane throughout the day. So not worth the money.

I have extremely sensitive eyes and can only wear very specific mascaras, and this one doesn't bother my eyes at all! I also have very straight lashes and this is by far the best at holding a curl. It's super lightweight, it layers well, and it doesn't smudge at all despite my oily eyelids. The only cons are that I have very thin lashes so it's more lengthening than volumizing on me, and by the end of the tube's life, it does begin to flake a little. But this has still become my go-to mascara!

Did nothing for me. I feel like I have to apply 50 coats to get it to show up.

New favorite! Typically i love thicker mascaras that hold a clump- but this one is wet and helps lengthen and spread lashes. my lashes felt so long and pretty all day!! and the removal was easy as well! my only concern is how it rubbed off on my eyelids through the day, i did learn to set my eyes on days i wear this product. but absolutely amazing mascara!!

I wanted to loves this! I’ve experienced rubbing my eyes (albeit in the heat) and later looking in the mirror only to find a grayish hue under me eyes. CaliRay would never! I’m keeping as a backup bc I do like that it spreads my lashes well enough, But I want volume baby! The packaging is cute and sometimes there’s a bit too much product on the wand; the consistency is decent.

Great for sensitive eyes! Keeps my straight lashes up and curled for hours. I do notice the application can get a bit messy and it may flake over time.

Beautiful product. the formula for tubing mascara is perfect. I used this on my top and bottom lashes and it stayed all day. clean to remove with regular face wash without it getting everywhere. Better than the Lengthening Mascara by Merit in my opinion. The brush is perfect for getting tiny lashes at the corner of the eye. It lifts and seperates. It doesn't clump up with multiple layers. It held my lashes curled.

I love the length and volume but unfortunately it flakes very quickly. Even before I finish the rest of my makeup.